My favorite shades in the caviar sticks are Metallic Taupe and Rose Nude, but there are tons of shades and finishes to choose from.
Top to bottom is Laura Mercier in Metallic Taupe, CoverGirl in Lush, Kiko Milano in Rose Brown, e.l.f. in Rose Gold, and Laura Mercier in Nude Rose.
Out of the three drugstore cream shadow sticks I’ve tried, I think that this one is the closest dupe to the Laura Mercier.
The packaging and formula also seem super similar to Laura Mercier, and the metallic finish is lovely.